Subordination in Title: Understanding the Concept and Its Importance in Real Estate and Lending

Subordination in title is a legal concept in real estate transactions and lending that determines the priority of claims or liens on a property. It plays a crucial role in the hierarchy of rights and obligations attached to real estate assets, mainly when multiple parties are involved in the financing or ownership of a property. Subordination means that one claim is ranked lower in priority than another, which can have significant implications for the parties involved.

This article will explore the concept of subordination in title, its applications, and its importance in real estate, loans, and mortgages.

What is Subordination in Title?

Subordination refers to placing one claim or lien below another in terms of priority. In real estate, this often involves the priority of mortgages or other types of liens on a property. When a borrower takes out a mortgage to purchase or refinance a property, the lender typically places a lien on the property to secure the loan. However, in some cases, a second lender may also place a lien on the property, which could result in competing claims on the same asset.

Subordination agreements are legally binding arrangements that establish the priority of these liens. For example, if a second mortgage lender agrees to subordinate their lien to the first mortgage lender’s lien, the first lender’s claim to the property will take precedence over the second lender’s claim. In a foreclosure, the first lender will be paid off before the second lender.

The Mechanics of Subordination in Title

Subordination agreements determine the order in which creditors or lienholders will be paid in the event of a liquidation or foreclosure of the property. Typically, the priority of claims is established based on the order in which they were recorded. The first mortgage lien or claim on the property is considered “senior,” while any subsequent claims are considered “junior.” The senior lienholder has the right to be paid first, and junior lienholders receive payment only after the senior lienholder is satisfied.

However, there are situations where junior lienholders may wish to adjust their position about senior lienholders. This is where subordination comes into play. A junior lienholder might agree to subordinate their claim to allow a new senior lienholder to have priority, or in some cases, the parties may negotiate a subordination agreement to restructure the order of claims.

For instance, if a property owner wants to refinance their mortgage but already has a second mortgage in place, the second mortgage lender may agree to subordinate their lien to the new first mortgage. In such cases, the second mortgage lender acknowledges that they will be paid only after the first mortgage is paid off in case of foreclosure. Still, they may benefit from the borrower’s improved financial position and better interest rates from the refinancing.

Why Subordination is Important in Real Estate

Subordination in title plays a significant role in ensuring clarity and stability in real estate transactions. Here are some of the key reasons why subordination is essential:

Facilitates Refinancing: Subordination agreements are significant when refinancing a mortgage. A property owner who wishes to refinance their first mortgage may need to have the second mortgage subordinated to the new loan. Without this, the lender refinancing the primary mortgage may not be willing to move forward if they don’t have priority over the second lienholder.
Protects Lenders and Investors: Subordination helps lenders assess risk by clearly outlining the priority of claims on the property. Lenders will be more inclined to offer loans if they understand their position in the event of foreclosure. A lender may help facilitate a new loan or financing deal by subordinating a junior lienholder’s position, which can benefit all parties involved.
Increases the Borrower’s Borrowing Capacity: For borrowers, subordination can make it easier to access additional financing. Suppose a junior lender agrees to subordinate their lien. In that case, the borrower may be able to secure a new first mortgage with better terms. This can improve the borrower’s financial position and make them eligible for better interest rates, increasing their borrowing capacity.
Clarifies the Priority of Claims: In situations involving multiple liens, subordination helps establish a clear priority of claims. This clarity is crucial in a foreclosure, as it determines how creditors will be repaid. Without a formal subordination agreement, disputes about the priority of claims may arise, leading to delays and complications.
Enables Real Estate Transactions: Subordination is essential to many real estate transactions. When a property owner has multiple liens or mortgages, a subordination agreement ensures that the buyer or lender understands the existing claims on the property and their relative priority. This transparency helps smooth the process of buying, selling, or refinancing a property.

Types of Subordination in Real Estate

In real estate transactions, subordination can be applied in different ways depending on the parties involved and the goals of the transaction. Some of the common types of subordination include:

Mortgage Subordination: This is the most common form of subordination, where a second mortgage holder agrees to subordinate their lien to a new first mortgage. This often occurs during refinancing, where the existing lender (first mortgage holder) agrees to allow the borrower to take on a new first mortgage with a different lender.
Subordination of Liens: In some cases, property owners may have multiple liens against their property, such as tax liens, judgment liens, or mechanic’s liens. A subordination agreement may modify the priority of these liens in favor of a senior lienholder. This ensures that the senior lienholder is repaid first in case of liquidation.
Subordination of Judgment Liens: When a property owner has been sued, and a judgment lien has been placed on the property, the creditor holding the judgment lien may agree to subordinate their claim to another lienholder. This can be important for borrowers who want to refinance or secure additional financing while managing judgment liens.

Key Considerations for Subordination Agreements

While subordination in title can be beneficial, it is essential to consider the following factors before agreeing:

Risk for Junior Lienholders: Junior lienholders face the risk of receiving little or no repayment if the property is foreclosed upon, particularly when subordinating their lien to a new senior loan. In such cases, they may want to negotiate favorable terms or safeguards to protect their interests.
The Impact on Interest Rates and Terms: The subordination of a junior lienholder may influence the terms and conditions of the new senior loan, including interest rates, repayment schedules, and other factors. Borrowers and lenders must assess whether the new loan terms are favorable for all parties involved.
Legal Advice: Subordination agreements are legal documents, and all parties should review their terms carefully. Borrowers and lenders may wish to seek legal counsel to ensure that their interests are protected and that the agreement is executed correctly.

Conclusion

Subordination in title is an essential concept in real estate and lending that determines the priority of claims on a property. Subordination agreements help facilitate refinancing, protect lenders and borrowers, and clarify real estate transactions by clearly outlining the hierarchy of liens and mortgages. Whether you’re a homeowner, a lender, or an investor, understanding the role of subordination can help you make more informed decisions about your property and financing options.

Learn more about our comprehensive title insurance services here.

Thank you for reading! If you enjoyed this article and want to explore more content on similar topics, check out our other blogs at Sonic Loans, Sonic Realty, and Sonic Title. We have a wealth of information designed to help you navigate the world of real estate and finance. Happy reading!

Provider and Settlement Service	Charge or Range of Charges
Sonic Realty LLC	1%-6% of purchase price
Sonic Title Agency, LLC	Title Insurance Policy: $950 - $1706 on a $250,000 property. (Rates vary and are dependent on the state, selling price, and loan amount on the property.) Title Search Fee: $250 - $325 (where applicable) Closing Fee: $450 - $650
Sonic Loans Inc. This company provides various real estate mortgage loan origination activities either as a third-party originator or a mortgage broker, including loan pre-qualification, competitive bid process (when providing third-party origination services), loan origination, loan pre-approval, loan structuring, processing, and closing.	Loan Origination Charge: 0-3 % of loan amount (may include 3^rd party fees) Loan Discount Fee/points: 0.5%-6% of loan amount. Application/Processing Fee: $0.00 - $875.00 Flood and tax service: $0.00 - $95.00 Underwriting Fee: $0.00 - $1295.00 Document Review Fee: $0.00 - $400.00 Appraisal Fee: $0.00 - $850.00 Credit Report Fee: $0.00 - $135.00 Actual charges may vary according to the particular lender selected, the particular services provided, and the underlying transaction, borrower selections, etc. Some or all of these fees may be charged by third parties and/or the Member Mortgage Lender/Mortgage Broker. The Member Lenders and Mortgage Brokers have agreed to pay a fee ranging from 0.5% to 2.75% of the loan amount to Sonic Loans in connection with a range of loan origination services provided by Sonic Loans to the Member Lender/Mortgage Broker. The fees are paid either directly to Sonic Loans by the Member Lender/Mortgage Broker or billed directly to you at closing.

Provider and Settlement Service	Charge or Range of Charges
Appraisal Fee	$0-$800
Credit Report Fee	$63-$125

Subordination in Title: Understanding the Concept and Its Importance in Real Estate and Lending